Horwitz Defense: what should Black play?
- Games played
- 24M
- To move
- Black
- Evaluation
- +0.16
- Depth
- 25
Game counts: Lichess opening book. Move ranking and evaluation: Stockfish. How this page is built
Black to playPosition before the recommended move. Green arrow: the recommended move.
One way to reach it: 1. d4 e6 2. Nf3
FEN
rnbqkbnr/pppp1ppp/4p3/8/3P4/5N2/PPP1PPPP/RNBQKB1R b KQkq -Understanding the position: d5 and the alternatives
In the Horwitz Defense, Black's most reliable and statistically dominant continuation is d5, securing central territory and anchoring the d5 square. This move appears in 68.1% of recorded games (17M recorded) and holds an engine evaluation of +0.16. Alternatives such as Nf6 or c5 offer viable transpositions, but establishing the classical pawn front remains the primary recommendation.
The Primary Line: d5
Playing d5 stakes an immediate claim in the center, typically steering play toward traditional Queen's Pawn setups or French Defense structures. White scores 54.5% from this position across 17M games. An illustrative engine continuation demonstrates a standard central struggle via d5 c4 Nf6 Nc3 Bb4 Bg5, where Black develops active piece play against White's queenside pressure.
Flexible Alternatives: Nf6 and c5
For players preferring dynamic pawn breaks or delayed commitments, both c5 and Nf6 represent solid choices. The flank strike c5 accounts for 14.1% of games (3.44M recorded) with an evaluation of +0.32, where White scores 53.0%; it can quickly pivot into open structures as shown in c5 e4 cxd4 Nxd4 Nc6 Nc3. Meanwhile, Nf6 is chosen in 12.2% of games (2.99M recorded, +0.19 evaluation), often transposing back into the main paths via Nf6 c4 d5 Nc3 Bb4 Bg5.
Less Common Responses: f5 and a6
Black can also opt for the Dutch-style advance f5, which features in 5.6% of games (1.37M recorded) with an engine evaluation of +0.39 and a 50.8% score for White. An illustrative sequence runs f5 Bf4 Nf6 e3 b6 Be2. Finally, the modest waiting move a6 carries an evaluation of +0.42 and leads toward lines such as a6 Nc3 d5 e4 Nf6 e5.
What else gets played here
Move choices from 24M games in the opening book, with the engine's evaluation of each.
| Move | Evaluation | Played | Games | White score |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| d5Engine pick | +0.16 | 17M | 54% | |
| c5 | +0.32 | 3.44M | 53% | |
| Nf6 | +0.19 | 2.99M | 53% | |
| f5 | +0.39 | 1.37M | 51% | |
| a6 | +0.42 | — | — | — |
Evaluation in pawns, from White's point of view: + favours White, − favours Black. White score: White's wins plus half the draws, over the games where that move was played and the result is known.
The line
More positions in the Horwitz Defense
- Black to playBest moveNf6Knight g8 → f6Horwitz Defense13M games
- White to playBest moved5Pawn d4 → d5Horwitz Defense5.74M games
- White to playBest moveNf3Knight g1 → f3Horwitz Defense5.36M games
- Black to playBest moveNf6Knight g8 → f6Horwitz Defense5.01M games
- White to playBest moved5Pawn d4 → d5Horwitz Defense1.67M games
- White to playBest moveNf3Knight g1 → f3Horwitz Defense221K games
Frequently asked questions
What is the best move for Black in the Horwitz Defense?
Black to play. Stockfish recommends d5 (Pawn d7 → d5), evaluated at +0.16: Equal.
How often does this position occur?
This position has been reached 24M times in the opening book.