C72Ruy Lopez

Ruy Lopez: Morphy Defense, Modern Steinitz Defense: what should Black play?

Best move

b5+0.38White is slightly better

Pawn b7 → b5

Close behind: Nf6 (+0.38)

Analyze this position →
Games played
974K
To move
Black
Evaluation
+0.38
Depth
25

Game counts: Lichess opening book. Move ranking and evaluation: Stockfish. How this page is built

Black to playPosition before the recommended move. Green arrow: the recommended move.

One way to reach it: 1. e4 e5 2. Nf3 Nc6 3. Bb5 a6 4. Ba4 d6 5. O-O

FENr1bqkbnr/1pp2ppp/p1np4/4p3/B3P3/5N2/PPPP1PPP/RNBQ1RK1 b kq -

Understanding the position: b5 and the alternatives

In the Modern Steinitz Defense of the Ruy Lopez (ECO C72), Black faces a pivotal choice after White castles. The engine's top recommendation is the expansion b5, which breaks the pin along the a4–e8 diagonal and holds an engine evaluation of +0.38 across 369K recorded games. By contesting queenside space and questioning the a4, Black gains tempo to complete minor-piece development.

Queenside Expansion with 5... b5

Playing b5 represents the most frequent choice, selected in 37.9% of the 974K games recorded from this tabiya. An illustrative continuation provided by the engine runs b5 Bb3 Nf6 c3 Be7 d4, where White retreats the bishop to b3 and prepares a central push while Black develops standard piece harmony. Against this setup, White scores 55.4% of points.

Counterattacking with 5... Nf6

The direct developmental move Nf6 matches the engine's +0.38 evaluation and accounts for 20.6% of recorded games (200K games). The line Nf6 c3 Nxe4 d4 Bd7 Re1 shows Black immediately challenging White's central pawn on e4. White scores 54.8% against this dynamic approach, which accepts tactical complications in the center.

Alternatives with the Light-Squared Bishop

Black also frequently resolves the position by developing the bishop. The solid Bd7 occurs in 22.3% of games (217K recorded, +0.41 eval), neutralizing the pin directly and leading into lines such as Bd7 c3 g6 d4 Bg7 h3, where White scores 53.4%. Alternatively, the active pin Bg4 is chosen in 16.7% of games (163K recorded, +0.56 eval), followed by Bg4 h3 Bh5 c3 Be7 d4, in which White scores 49.5%. A quieter setup via Be7 appears in 2.5% of games (25K recorded, +0.40 eval), continuing Be7 c3 Nf6 Re1 b5 Bc2 with a 55.7% White score.

What else gets played here

Move choices from 974K games in the opening book, with the engine's evaluation of each.

MoveEvaluationPlayedGamesWhite score
b5Engine pick+0.3838%369K55%
Bd7+0.4122%217K53%
Nf6+0.3821%200K55%
Bg4+0.5617%163K50%
Be7+0.403%25K56%

Evaluation in pawns, from White's point of view: + favours White, − favours Black. White score: White's wins plus half the draws, over the games where that move was played and the result is known.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best move for Black in the Ruy Lopez: Morphy Defense, Modern Steinitz Defense?

Black to play. Stockfish recommends b5 (Pawn b7 → b5), evaluated at +0.38: White is slightly better.

How often does this position occur?

This position has been reached 974K times in the opening book.